'Winter' for Brothers
4 Dec 2009138
Comments
138
Terezam
06 December, 2009 incredible
I have listened to this 20 - 30 times this morning and its incredible...where can I buy the single!!! Bonos voice at the end is heartbreaking...LOVE it
Hardfelt
06 December, 2009 greater than 1
Never ceases to amaze me how U2 have a deft gift for making multiple versions of the same song. I was a huge fan of this track when I heard it on the Linear film and read somewhere (I think) that Eno pushed for its inclusion on the NLOTH album. Understandable. I imagine that its incarnation here is a nice response to the film. Nice work
dan_smee
06 December, 2009 Winter
Love it. I don't understand people complaining about it being different from the other version, We already have that one, so it is great to have a different take. Also fits the movie perfectly. I prefer this version, and the vocal is amazing
nat 2A
06 December, 2009 !!!!
very different from the linear.
wonderful acoustic version!!!
claire17
06 December, 2009 brilliant
beautiful melody and magnificent voice as usual pfff
adamman32
06 December, 2009 good stuff
I thought that was good. Not only was it a good song but it was very appropriate for the mood of the movie as well.
lazee97
06 December, 2009 great song. however...
This is a great song and seems like it would fit the movie brothers really well but I do like the original version from Linear better. Hopefully they will release that version on Songs of Ascent
u2liftmysoul
06 December, 2009 Bono's voice is beautiful on this track!
Like almost every U2 song...something beautiful, refreshing, new, magical...What a poetic song; can't wait to see it in the movie!!!!
MJHeff
06 December, 2009 Linear
Both versions have great potential as a live track. Kind of depends on how U2 want to portray the song live. Could be a great acoustic track.
cugini
06 December, 2009 very gooddddddd
Hi from Italy.
this version is Amazing..
MRamos
06 December, 2009 We are waiting to hear alive.
Beautiful version and the vocal is sublime.
We are waiting for U2 show 360 in South America, specificly in Brazil and we hope hear this song alive.
Alisaura
06 December, 2009 Um.. no.
I didn't like the version on Linear much, and this is worse. I'm sorry, but Bono's voice sounds awful.
electricco
06 December, 2009 Songs of Ascents . . .
And Winter ! love the Linear version cos its Work So Well - the trip thru France & Spain . . . Kingdom . . .
Samyx94
06 December, 2009 Great song!
I think it's really nice, I love this song from the first listen.
borjaosant
06 December, 2009 both are great
eveb though i realy prefer the strongest track in linear
buffalo_bill
06 December, 2009 beautiful
Beautiful song.Bono's voice is super.
eamonnm
05 December, 2009 Winter's back!
loved this track on linear, sorry it didn't stay on the album, so maybe this is the reason....great alt version, this is really nice and I'm sure suits the mood of the movie, and the voice of Bono will lend to that here...like many others lets get some release of both versions asap...and maybe even hear it live in Vienna for U2010.
nmbr1u2fan
05 December, 2009 Prefer original still
This sounds good but the swailing piano and Edges guitar playing behind Bono's vocals in the original still take the cake for me.
bosko
05 December, 2009 Nice but too slow
I honestly have been so excited & hopeful to hear this track finished on the next record. This takes it in a totally new direction which I am not feeling nearly as much. I would like it a lot if I didn't already love the other.
kris_smith87
05 December, 2009 Unsure
I really enjoy the Linear version, and this version is really quite different. I really want to hear the full version though, when will it be released?
007sista
05 December, 2009 Brothers Soundcheck
Its interesting...I've heard many of U2 soundtracks from movies and honestly was never impress with them except In The Name of the Father and Lara Croft: Tomb Raider...I think its different for U2 because its unique and mature...The sound doesn't try to win over the teeny-pop crowd but a crowd of people who want to listen to a narrative within a song...I haven't saw Brothers yet so even when I see the movie this song would simply be a part of its soundtrack..
Yogic
05 December, 2009 BRAVO
WINTER is a perfect flow for this Innocent webby Brothers movie that's rich with deep emotional impact...far from dorment... Bonus Scene with U2 BAD from the Boom Box... also well pivoting done : ).
kitemaster
05 December, 2009 WHAT THE ?
Why not let us hear the full song ??
Why is this version not on the CD soundtrack?
pragakhan
05 December, 2009 never change the original
never change the orignal its good for the movie but i wanna hear the linear track
jazzyjoesig
05 December, 2009 empathetic
To me, this version of the song brings out emotions like sorrow and self pity while at the same time grace and empathy. This reminds me of the "remastered" sometimes you can't make it or side two from the Joshua tree. I wish U2 would go with their gut and release whats true to their heart versus working with producers to try to make the top ten. That will come...
bosslady
05 December, 2009 Sweet
Bono's voice is truly sweet to the ear...his range of notes is breathtaking...could sit and listen all day!
05 December, 2009
---
So beautiful! I really wanted to hear this song in a concert.
lionfish
05 December, 2009 Prefer the original
I like the original song way better. Some of the lyrics are better though, but it doesn't give me goosebumps and the original does.....every time!
saissiun
05 December, 2009 Great...
HelloHelloHolaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa...
I prefer that one !
The song is better... with the guitar...
With the wonderful voice of the singer !
Who's that singer ???
Great song...
Sebastien
==========================================
contos
05 December, 2009 very nice
My 7 year old song is humming along as I write this. Give us SOA please. We dont care about radio crap anyway.
Newer comments 61 - 90 of 138 Older comments
RECENT NEWS
